THE ROSARY MURDERS

Wary in the confessional: Donald Sutherland

THE ROSARY MURDERS (1987). Director: Fred Walton.

"We're saving souls -- not lives."

Father Robert Koesler (Donald Sutherland of Invasion of the Body Snatchers) discovers that someone is targeting members of the clergy, shooting a priest and faking a nun's suicide. In a steal from Hitchcock's I Confess, the killer confronts Father Koesler in the confessional, and after surviving the encounter, the priest does his own investigation. He learns who the killer probably is but doesn't inform the police, not wishing to betray the sanctity of the confessional. (While it makes sense that a more conservative priest, like Father Nabors, played by Charles Durning of Sisters, would adhere to canonical law, Koesler is portrayed as being more liberal.) Because of his inaction, there are several more deaths, for which Lt. Koznicki (Josef Sommers) clearly blames him. 

Charles Durning

The Rosary Murders, based on the novel by former priest William X. Kienzle, has an interesting storyline, but there's something strangely unsatisfying about the movie. The film is directed by Fred Walton, best known for When a Stranger Calls -- he also co-wrote the screenplay with Elmore Leonard -- but you get the feeling that he's holding back, that he really wanted to craft an all-out horror film instead of a suspense picture, but felt too restricted. There are a couple of creepy scenes in the movie, but a kind of almost amateurish sheen that makes the whole project seem second-rate, despite its good points and the fact that it is fast-paced and absorbing. The movie completely lacks a sense of urgency, even though people, including police officers, are dropping like flies! (I would have loved to have seen what Italian giallo director Dario Argento could have done with this material!)

James Murtaugh

Another problem is that Donald Sutherland isn't well cast and gives an unremarkable performance, possibly because the character is irritating in some ways and contradictory. Durning is fine, as always, and James Murtaugh scores as a parishioner whose teenage daughter committed suicide. Belinda Bauer is given the thankless role of a reporter who becomes friends with Father Koesler and apparently falls in love with him -- one of the least convincing "romances" in the history of the movies ( and which should have been left on the cutting room floor). The movie at times seems vastly over-scored. Kienzle wrote many more books in the Father Koesler series, turning the priest into an amateur sleuth, and engendering the Protestant Reverend Randollph novels as well. 

Verdict: Intriguing plot carries this along despite deficiencies. ***.

WHEN A STRANGER CALLS (1979)

Carol Kane

WHEN A STRANGER CALLS (1979). Director/co-writer: Fred Walton.

Babysitter Jill Johnson (Carol Kane of The Mafu Cage) is terrorized by a caller who keeps asking her if she's checked on the kids. When the police manage to trace the call Jill gets an unpleasant surprise. Years later John Clifford (Charles Durning), a former cop on the case, is hired by the children's father to find Curt Duncan (Tony Beckley), the psychopath who turned his life upside down and who has escaped from an asylum. Clifford tracks Duncan down, but can he stop him permanently before he goes after the terrified babysitter, Jill, who is now a grown woman with children of her own?

Charles Durning

I believe that When a Stranger Calls was expanded from a short film, The Sitter, which comprised only the chilling opening sequence of this movie. The middle section of this film stills holds interest, as it focuses on Duncan, his interactions with barfly (but not drunken) Tracy (Colleen Dewhurst of Annie Hall), and Clifford's efforts to track down Duncan, whom he intends to murder. (A powerful scene has Clifford telling Tracy exactly how Duncan killed two innocent young children.) The final section of the film is another chilling sequence with Duncan, Jill, and her family. In fact the climax may outdo the prologue in creepiness.

Colleen Dewhurst and Tony Beckley

When a Stranger Calls manages to sustain tension via generally good direction and Dana Kaproff's simple but very effective musical score. There are also solid performances, with Beckley and Dewhurst as standouts, although there is very good work from Durning [Sisters] and a mush-mouthed Carol Kane. Rachel Roberts has one scene as a psychiatrist in the institution that Duncan escaped from, and Ron O'Neal is on the mark as a cop colleague of Clifford's. The atmospheric photography is by Don Peterson. One wishes that there was more character development, however, both of the psycho and of Tracy. What little we learn of the latter is due chiefly to Dewhurst's performance. This was busy British actor Tony Beckley's last film; he died the following year.

A very good sequel, When a Stranger Calls Back, came out in 1993. And there was a remake in 2006.

Verdict: Absorbing horror-suspense film. ***.