 |
| Kim Novak with Pyewacket |
BELL BOOK AND CANDLE (1958). Director: Richard Quine.
Shepherd Henderson (James Stewart) lives in Manhattan above an esoteric shop run by the beautiful Gillian Holroyd (Kim Novak). Gillian is a witch, and she decides to use a potion to draw Shep away from his fiancee, Merle (Janice Rule), whom she knew in college and didn't like. Before you know it, Shep is breaking it off with Merle on the day of their marriage and declaring his love for Gillian, even though she believes witches can't feel true love. When Gillian's brother, Nicky (Jack Lemmon), learns the truth, he and author Sidney Redlitch (Ernie Kovacs) -- who is working on a book about witches with Nicky -- ask head witch Mrs de Passe (Hermione Gingold of
Gigi) to intercede. Once the spell is removed, will Shep and Gillian discover that their feelings for one another are actually real?
 |
| Battling siblings: Novak and Lemmon |
Based on a play by James Van Druten,
Bell Book and Candle should be an exercise in charming whimsy, but instead it's a leaden bit of foolishness. There are intriguing elements to the picture -- including the notion that, like gay people (not to compare the two!), witches can hide in plain sight -- but the film never recovers from the fact that Gillian at times comes off like a psycho -- her revenge upon Merle while in college is definite overkill. The whole business with witches and warlocks being some kind of secret society isn't handled very well in any case. One would think the performances of the cast would help put this over, but no one -- not even Stewart -- distinguishes himself; Elsa Lanchester [
Murder By Death] as Novak's aunt offers her usual dithery portrayal and nothing more. Kim Novak affects a curious speech pattern that sort of fits her role. I must say I
was impressed with Gillian's cat, Pyewacket, who slinks through the picture with aplomb.
 |
| Bewitched and befuddled: Stewart |
Even considering that he's under a spell, Shep discards his fiance in an abrupt and cruel fashion (admittedly he should never have gotten engaged to her in the first place). With its premise of a witch with powers falling in love with an "outsider" or ordinary human,
Bell Book and Candle is the obvious progenitor of the TV show
Bewitched, which debuted six years later. The contributions of George Duning and James Wong Howe are wasted on this comparative piffle. I think the biggest problem is that this was made the same year as Hitchcock's masterpiece
Vertigo, and considering it has the same two stars,
Bell very, very much suffers in comparison.
Verdict:
I Married a Witch this isn't! **1/4.
2 comments:
Aww, Bill, I wish you loved this one as much as I do! I think it's a delight from start to finish, and has grown into one of my favorite films! I do think it's Kim Novak's finest performance (and you re right, she does play quite a vengeful b*tch!) I think Stewart and Novak have great chemistry--this movie is no Vertigo, but the starts carry it with strong charisma and star quality. It's a comedy with quite an edge--I love the beatnik jazz motif of the Zodiac Club. I think it's one of Jack Lemmon's most engaging early roles, and I disagree with you about Kovaks...I think he's great here. Love Janice Rule and the Stormy Weather hex scene, too! Add Elsa Lanchester and Hermione Gingold and it's an all-star black comedy romance romp. Oh, and Pyewacket steals the film! :-)
-Chris
Well, at least we agree about Pyewacket, LOL! Y'know I wish I had enjoyed this more. Maybe at some future time period I'll give it another looksee. Now that you mention it, I think you're right that it has an edge.
Post a Comment