 |
| Rise Stevens and Nelson Eddy |
THE CHOCOLATE SOLDIER (1941). Director: Roy Del Ruth.
Karl Lang (Nelson Eddy) and Maria Lanyl (Rise Stevens) are a married couple in Vienna who appear nightly in a production of
The Chocolate Soldier. Karl is generally surrounded by adoring young ladies, but he is still jealous of the attentions his wife receives from other men, and thinks that she has quite a romantic history. He fears it is time for her to take yet another lover and his marriage may be doomed. To test Maria's affections, he disguises himself as an intensely romantic Russian singer ...
 |
| Eddy disguised as the Russian |
Like
Sweethearts, which Eddy did with Jeanette MacDonald three years earlier,
The Chocolate Soldier completely throws out the plot of that operetta -- while retaining some of Oscar Straus' music -- and substitutes the storyline of that creaky old standby
The Guardsman (which Lunt and Fontanne actually filmed ten years earlier). This plot was recycled for more than one
I Love Lucy episode which at least had Lucy and Desi yukking it up. However, to be fair to the leads in this picture, they are both excellent and amusing in their own way. Often damned as a lousy actor, Eddy is actually quite effective in this, including when he is impersonating the love-mad Russian. Stevens, a mezzo-soprano to reckon with and a genuine operatic star (and with a voice far superior to Jeanette MacDonald's ), also proves a delightfully talented and sophisticated actress. Stevens may not have been a stunning beauty, but with her personality, manner and charm -- not to mention her cute appeal -- I have no doubt she had plenty of male admirers (she was happily married for 61 years, however).
 |
| Nelson Eddy as Karl |
But then we come to the music. The best song, of course, is the gorgeous "My Hero," which is reprised more than once in the movie and deserves to be. Vivian Vance sang this song in the classic "Ethel's Home Town" episode of
I Love Lucy, but while Vance had a nice voice, she can't compare to Stevens, who gives a superb rendition, joined in by Eddy, who is also in fine voice, at one point. Stevens is also given a beautiful aria from
Samson and Delilah, while Eddy does
Tannhauser. There are other musical interludes, including a weird, unmemorable piece sung by Eddy as the Russian, and a frenetically-edited dance at a drinking establishment.
 |
| Rise Stevens |
Frankly, the script for
Chocolate Soldier is not the chief appeal of the movie, although it does manage to remain amusing and watchable due to the actors and the soundtrack. Florence Bates [
The Brasher Doubloon], Nigel Bruce, and Nydia Westman [
Forty Little Mothers] add to the fun as assorted associates of the lead couple, and all are very good. Rise Stevens did a version of
The Chocolate Soldier for television with Eddie Albert in 1955, which I believe stuck to the original story of the operetta. Stevens had a long and wonderful career with the Metropolitan opera in New York and did very few films, one of which was
Going My Way. She did a few operas, such as
Carmen, on TV as well.
Verdict: Despite its obvious flaws, this is still quite entertaining. "My Hero," indeed! ***.
3 comments:
Hi Bill - I guess if I were to pick a Nelson film as an introduction, this would be it, even if McDonald is not in it. I remember Rise Stevens from some Disney recordings she did when i was a kid, and of course I remember Ethel singing "My Hero" on I Love Lucy! I will check it out.
-Chris
This pic was a pleasant surprise. I didn't miss MacDonald because she's never really beewn one of my favorites.
Post a Comment